1200px

Best Pennsylvania Online Casinos - Guide to PA Online Gambling

Learn all about gambling and real money online casinos in Pennsylvania.

Pennsylvania State Guide

While the rollout of Pennsylvania online gambling faced delays after delays, the state finally legalized online casinos in October 2017.

As a result, PA residents now have opportunities to access a range of online casinos to enjoy the thrill of gambling from anywhere. Here you will get a snapshot of the best online casinos, the current legal situation, and the requirements for playing in any Pennsylvania casino.

Let's begin by examining the types of gambling that are legal in Pennsylvania:
✅ Online Casino & Land-Based Casino
✅ Social and Sweepstakes Casinos
✅ Online Sports Betting & Land-Based Sports Betting
✅ Daily Fantasy Sports
✅ Horse Racing
✅ Charitable Gambling
✅ Online Bingo & Land-Based Bingo
✅ Online Poker & Land-Based Poker
The Greatest Baccarat Wins of All Time
news
Maximize Your Rewards Every Thursday with Tropicana Casino NJ's Tier Credit Escalator
Promotions
B Spot No Deposit Bonus I Get $10 in Freeplay
Promotions

Top Casinos

FAQ

  • Is online gambling legal in Pennsylvania?

  • When did online gambling become legal in Pennsylvania?

  • Are casinos at CasinoTalk licensed?

  • How do I know if a casino is licensed in Pennsylvania?

  • Do online casinos in PA offer No Deposit Bonuses?

  • Which banking options can I use to deposit money into an online casino in Pennsylvania?

  • Can you win real money at online casinos in PA?

  • Can I play online casino games in Pennsylvania for free?

  • What's the best online casino in PA?

  • How many online casinos are in PA?

Pennsylvania Online Casinos

The Pennsylvania online gambling industry has grown faster than we had foreseen. As a result, several land-based casinos in PA have received licenses for online operations. 

As the market expands, it's crucial to explore the top legal online casinos in the state. The most popular online casinos in Pennsylvania include the likes of DraftKings, Caesars, and BetMGM, but there are currently more than 20 casino brands to choose from. Check below for the current best and most up-to-date casino bonus offers in PA

CasinoPromotion OfferPromo Code
🎰 BetMGM Casino$25  FreePlay® and 100% up to $1500 SQORESPINS
🎰 Borgata Casino$20 FreePlay + 100% up to $1000TALK20
🎰 Caesars Palace Casino100% up to $2,500 + 2500 Reward Credits®CASMIX2500
🎰 DraftKings Casino100% up to $2,000 + 50 Bonus CreditsNONE NEEDED

Gambling Problem? Call or TEXT 1-800-Gambler 21+

Is Online Gambling in Pennsylvania Legal and Safe?

Yes, it is legal and you are safe when playing in any regulated PA online casino. First and foremost, the legislation ensures that all casinos are operating legally, and the legislation provides the latest security features to ensure safety.

Everyone knows that a licensed casino is the safest casino because it is continually being checked for irregularities. At the moment, all legit state online casinos in PA are licensed by the Gaming Control Board of Pennsylvania, which means you can trust them.

If you have any concerns about providing details, you should know that your data is safe thanks to deploying the latest encryption layers to keep data breaches at bay.

Additionally, the law requires Pennsylvania’s regulated online casino sites to keep the player’s funds in separate bank accounts. That way, if the systems of a gaming platform are ever hacked (which is practically impossible), the hackers still won’t gain access to your funds. This means your money is always kept safe, and you can cash out whenever you want.

The payment methods that you’ll find in any regulated PA online casinos also meet the airtight international security standards to guarantee secure and safe financial transactions.

The Best PA Casino Bonus Offers

Real-money online casinos in Pennsylvania offer a variety of casino bonuses and promotions to attract new players and retain existing ones. These promotions can significantly enhance your gambling experience and provide opportunities to increase your winnings. However, it's essential to understand the terms and conditions associated with each offer to make the most of them.

Types of Promotions and Bonuses

Bonuses and promotions at real money online casinos come in different forms and shapes but these are the most common types:

First Deposit Bonuses:

  • Fist deposit bonuses are offered to new players upon signing up or making their first deposit.
  • They typically come in the form of a match bonus, where the casino matches a percentage of your initial deposit, up to a certain amount.
  • For example, a 100% match bonus up to $500 means that if you deposit $500, you'll receive an additional $500 in bonus funds.
CasinoFirst Deposit Bonus OfferPromo Code
BetMGM Casino
$25 Freeplay®️ and 100% up to $1000 Deposit BonusSQORESPINS
 Borgata Casino
$20 Freeplay®️ + 100% up to $1000 Deposit BonusTALK20
 Caesars Palace Casino
100% up to $2,500 + 2500 Reward Credits®CASMIX2500
 Bet365 Casino
100% up to $1,000 Deposit BonusTALK1000
 Golden Nugget Casino
100% up to $1,000 + 200 Free SpinsNONE NEEDED
DraftKings Casino
100% up to $2,000 + 50 Bonus CreditsNONE NEEDED
 Party Casino
100% up to $500 + 100 Free SpinsTALK1000

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (NJ, PA, WV), or 1-800-270-7117 for confidential help (MI). 

No Deposit Bonuses:

  • Some online casinos may offer no deposit bonuses, where players receive bonus funds or free spins without having to deposit any money.
  • No deposit bonuses are a great way to try out a casino's games without risking your own funds.
Online CasinoBonus ReviewNo Deposit Bonus
BorgataBorgata No Deposit Bonus$20 Cash Bonus + Up to $1000 Bonus
BetMGMBetMGM No Deposit Bonus$25 Cash Bonus + Up to $1000 Bonus
Wheel of FortuneWOF No Deposit Bonus$25 Cash Bonus + Up to $2500 Bonus 
DraftKingsDraftKings No Deposit BonusUp to $2000 Bonus
Golden NuggetGolden Nugget No Deposit BonusUp to $1000 Bonus + 200 Bonus Spins

Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER (NJ, PA, WV), or 1-800-270-7117 for confidential help (MI).

Free Spins:

  • Free spins are commonly offered as part of welcome bonuses or promotions for specific slot games.
  • They allow players to spin the reels of a slot machine without using their own money, with the potential to win real prizes.

Reload Bonuses:

  • Reload bonuses are similar to welcome bonuses but are offered to existing players when they make subsequent deposits.
  • They are designed to incentivize players to continue playing at the casino and reload their accounts.

Cashback Offers:

  • Cashback bonuses provide players with a percentage of their losses back as bonus funds.
  • These promotions can help mitigate losses and extend your gameplay sessions.

Understanding Terms and Conditions

By understanding the terms and conditions of a casino bonus, you can make informed decisions and maximize your rewards. Here are four common restrictions:

  • Wagering Requirements: Most bonuses come with wagering requirements, which specify the amount of money you need to wager before you can withdraw any winnings associated with the bonus. These requirements are typically represented as a multiple of the bonus amount or the bonus plus deposit amount.
  • Expiration Dates: Bonuses usually have expiration dates, after which they expire and become void. It's essential to use bonuses within the specified time frame to avoid forfeiting them.
  • Game Restrictions: Some bonuses may be restricted to specific games or game types. Make sure to check the terms and conditions to see which games are eligible for bonus wagering.
  • Maximum Bet Limits: Many bonuses come with maximum bet limits, which restrict the amount you can wager per spin or bet while the bonus is active. Exceeding these limits can result in the forfeiture of the bonus and any associated winnings.

Tips for Maximizing Bonuses

These are four aspects to bear in mind to get the most out of the concept of casino bonuses:

✅ Read the Fine Print: Always carefully read the terms and conditions of any bonus offer to understand its requirements and restrictions.

✅ Choose Bonuses Wisely: Select bonuses that align with your gaming preferences and budget, and that offer reasonable wagering requirements.

✅ Manage Your Bankroll: Stick to a budget and avoid chasing losses, even when using bonus funds.

✅ Stay Informed: Keep an eye out for new promotions and bonuses offered by online casinos in Pennsylvania to take advantage of the best deals.

Best Casino Bonuses in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania
Betmgm
Caesars

How to Register, Fund Your Account, and Claim Bonus

Step by step guide on how to sign up with an online casino in Pennsylvania

Here's a step-by-step guide on registering a real money casino account in Pennsylvania and getting started with your gameplay:

1 Select your preferred casino and its promotional offer:

Choose any of the listed casinos on this page and take note of the promo code associated with the casino offer.

2 Complete the registration process:

Each casino may have a slightly different registration procedure, but generally, they require similar information. Provide the requested details, and your account will be validated promptly.

3 Deposit funds into your account:

This step involves making decisions based on your preferences and gaming strategy.

  • Ensure that your deposit is sufficient to activate the casino bonus you've selected.
  • Opt for a banking method that offers fast and convenient transactions.
  • We recommend using PayPal, or any other e-wallet, Credit, or Debit card, as our experience has shown these options to be the most efficient for transactions at PA online casinos.
4 Receive your bonus and start playing:

Once your account is created and funded, you'll typically receive your casino bonus instantly. With your bonus in hand, you're now ready to explore and enjoy a wide array of games!

The Variety of Casino Games in Pennsylvania Online Casinos

Pennsylvania's online casinos present an extensive array of beloved games. Here's a breakdown of the typical game categories you'll find:

Slots

Slots reign as the most extensive category of games in any online casino in Pennsylvania. With many casinos offering over 1,000 games, navigating through the list of slot titles requires effective sorting mechanisms.

  • Sorting Options: Casinos typically prioritize their most popular games. Players can utilize filters to search for specific criteria, such as the number of reels, game developer, presence of progressive jackpots, and more.
  • Live Casino Slots: Fans of live casino slots can indulge in many options online. Whether searching by name or browsing listings for renowned studios like IGT or Bally, players have ample choices for immersive slot experiences.
  • Classic Games: Online casinos feature a variety of classic slot games, including iconic titles like Starburst, Gonzo's Quest, Divine Fortune, and Cleopatra. Additionally, players can enjoy traditional three-reel slots crafted by online slot studios like IGT.
  • Progressive Jackpots: Many online slots showcase progressive jackpots, often reaching six-figure sums and occasionally surpassing $1 million.

Table Games

Table games encompass a wide range of casino classics traditionally played on the green felt. While predominantly card-based, this category also includes dice and roulette wheel games.

Notable Table Games:

  • Roulette: Players can bet on favorite numbers or experiment with complex betting systems, with European roulette offering a lower house edge due to its single zero.
  • Blackjack: Variations abound, featuring side bets, multi-hand options, and unique variants such as European Blackjack and Spanish 21.
  • Casino Poker Games: Pennsylvania's online casinos offer a plethora of poker options, including video poker variants like Jacks or Better and Deuces Wild, as well as multiplayer poker rooms featuring Texas Hold'em, Omaha, and more.
  • Craps: This lively game with its two betting phases and potential for hot streaks appears at select online casinos, providing players an opportunity to learn its intricacies.
  • Baccarat: With favorable odds on two of its three betting options, baccarat remains a favorite among high rollers seeking entertainment.

Live Dealer Games:

For an authentic casino experience, PA players can delve into live dealer games streamed in real-time from professional studios. You may interact with live dealers and fellow players while enjoying games like blackjack, roulette, baccarat, and casino hold 'em.

Casino Games Guides

Casino
roulette
Craps

Who Can Play Online Casino Games in Pennsylvania?

Seal

Regulated online casino sites in the Keystone State are not just for every Tom, Dick, and Harry. To ensure that safe gambling doesn’t get out of hand, the state lawmakers thoroughly defined who can play in PA online casinos for real money. So, if you are to be eligible for online gambling, you will have to meet the following player criteria:

  • You must be within the Pennsylvania State borders to play at any PA online casino.
  • You must be at least 21 years old to play for real money
  • You can fund your account from anywhere around the US, but playing for real money is restricted to PA only.

Stringent gambling laws

Compared to the rest of the world, online gaming laws in the United States are pretty stringent. Not all states have legalized online gambling and those that do have rules that define the activity uniquely. While the terms seem over the top, by regulating online gambling in this manner, PA state, in particular aims to meet the following goals;

  • To generate revenue for the state.
  • Ensure integrity of the various software used in online casinos.
  • Exclusive vetting of online casino license applicants
  • Make sure that casino games are fair to prevent partisan advantage for the house.
  • To monitor any violations by casino operators as well as players.

Before you start to gamble

You may also be interested to know that before you start gambling in any online Pennsylvania casino, there are a couple of verification processes that you must pass through first. 

  1. First, the casino will verify your location using geolocation software to confirm if you are in Pennsylvania.
  2. Next, you can also be asked to provide your social security number to verify that you are who you say you are.
  3. Finally, the gaming platform may also ask for proof of your physical address, which could require you to submit a copy of your credit card statement or recent utility bill.

Top-notch security

Although online payments were deemed insecure a while back, things have changed for the better thanks to recent innovations and international banking regulations. 

The latest security technologies, such as 128-bit encryption and two-factor authentication, have made online money transfers safer. These technological advancements have led to plenty of online banking options that we will cover in the later sections of this review.

Gambling as a Resident

Although you have to be at least 21 years, the current Pennsylvania laws have made online gambling easier for residents. All that’s left for you is to find a legitimate online casino and create a new online account. 

In most cases, you must make your first deposit to your account and grab a welcome bonus before you can start playing.  

Gambling as a Non-resident

If you are not a resident of the Keystone State, on the other hand, it is impossible to create an account in any online casino located in PA. This is due to the current law in the US, which compels online casinos to have geolocation software to track your location to ensure you are within state lines. 

Thus, if you try creating an account from a different place, you’ll get a notification from the site informing you that you aren’t within the eligible geographical boundary.

The Best Casino Apps in Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania, the rise of mobile casino apps has transformed the landscape of online gambling, offering players unprecedented convenience and accessibility. Among the plethora of options available, two standout examples are the BetMGM Casino app and the Caesars Casino app, both renowned for their reliability and user-friendly interfaces.

Pennsylvania online casino promos

Licensed by the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board (PGCB), these apps provide seamless access to a wide array of casino games, including slots, table games, and live dealer experiences, all optimized for mobile play. Whether you're an iOS or Android user, both BetMGM and Caesars offer dedicated apps tailored to your device.

Navigating through these apps is intuitive, with easy registration processes and straightforward account management features. With just a few taps on your smartphone or tablet, you can create an account, deposit funds securely, and start playing your favorite games within minutes.

Compatibility:

  • Casino apps in Pennsylvania are generally compatible with both iOS and Android devices.
  • Players can download the app directly from the App Store (for iOS users) or the Google Play Store (for Android users) or visit the casino's website to download the app directly.

Setting Up iOS & Android Casino Apps in Pennsylvania

Every licensed online casino in Pennsylvania provides its services via a dedicated casino or betting app, accessible on both iOS and Android devices. The process of downloading a casino app is intuitive and straightforward. To promptly start using your selected casino app, follow these three steps:

  1. Choose the casino you want to sign up with and click the provided link on this page.
  2. Complete the registration process.
  3. Once registered, log in to your account from your mobile device, where download links for the casino app will be readily available.

Safe Banking Options for PA Real Money Casinos

Real money online casinos in Pennsylvania offer a variety of payment methods that you can use to fund your accounts. Most PA online casinos have a conventional model for their payment methods. You’ll find that nearly all of them have similar payment methods on board. Here’s a look at all the most popular payment channels.

Deposit Options

Below is a quick highlight of all the most reliable deposit options available in most online casinos in Pennsylvania.

  • E-wallets: Neteller, Skrill, and PayPal.
  • Instant Money Transfers from checking accounts; ACH transfers, and online bill pay.
  • Debit/Credit Cards and Prepaid Cards: Credit and debit cards from MasterCard, Maestro, Discover, Visa, and American Express.

Many online casinos also offer site-branded prepaid cards. Unfortunately, it is not always possible to withdraw using prepaid cards because of this.

Withdrawals

However, you must note that players cannot use any method they like for depositing or withdrawing their earnings. To cash out, you are often limited to the following channels;

  • PayPal
  • Neteller
  • Skrill
  • Paper’s check
  • VIP transfer (VIP Preferred)
  • Bank Transfers

EChecks, PayPal, and ACH are exceptionally convenient out of all the mentioned payment methods. However, unlike instantly processed deposits across all payment options, you are subjected to minor delays when cashing out.

Moreover, the processing speeds for withdrawals will often vary from one payment option to another. For example, E-wallets are typically the fastest, with a same-day or maximum of 48 hours.  On the other hand, checks ACH transfers tend to be relatively slow, with processing speeds that could take about seven business days.

The casino usually does not charge for deposits and withdrawals, but payment options like Neteller and Skrill could still set you. However, it would help if you looked at the terms and conditions of the platform or contacted support for more information about transactional fees.

The other important thing to note is that you can only use e-wallets for withdrawals if you previously used them to make deposits to your account.

Physical Cash Transactions

If you prefer to keep your banking transactions off the internet, you will be pleased to know that you can also physically deposit via designated kiosks. This is all possible using a PayNearMe deposit which needs you to travel to a store like a 7-eleven store, CVS, or Family Dollar.

The other option you can also use for both deposits and withdrawals is Cash at the Casino Cage. If you happen to be close to any land-based casino, you need to visit the cashier’s cage, and you will be allowed to transfer money to your real money account. The best thing about using Cash Cage is that maximum transactional limits will not constrain you.

Banking Guides

7
circle
minimum

List of All Pennsylvania Online Casinos

Presently, Pennsylvania is home to 21 online casinos. Here is a detailed list of all PA online casinos and their respective land-based casino affiliates.

PA Online CasinoLand-Based Casino Partner
BetMGM Casino PA Hollywood Casino Morgantown
Caesars Palace Online Casino PAHarrah's Philadelphia
DraftKings Casino PAHollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course
FanDuel Casino PAValley Forge Casino Resort
Borgata Casino PARivers Casino Philadelphia
BetRivers Casino PARivers Casino Pittsburgh
Bally Casino PATBD
Caesars Sportsbook & Casino PAHarrah's Philadelphia
Unibet Casino PAMohegan Sun Pocono
Fanatics Casino PATBD
Tropicana Casino PATBD
Betway Casino PALive! Casino Hotel Philadelphia
PokerStars Casino PAMount Airy Casino Resort
BetParx Casino PAParx Casino
Hollywood Casino PAHollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course
Stardust Casino PAValley Forge Casino Resort
PlaySugarHouse Casino PARivers Casino Philadelphia
Wind Creek Casino PAWind Creek Bethlehem
PlayLive! Casino PALive! Casino Hotel Philadelphia
Golden Nugget Casino PATBD
Jackpot City Casino PATBD

Land-Based Casinos in Pennsylvania

Operators can choose to offer online slots, online table games, or even both if they want to. And many license applicants have applied for both licenses. The first regulated PA online casinos started operating on the market in 2018. The pacesetters of this new dawn included the likes of BetRivers Casino and BetMGM Online Casino and with time, many more operators followed suit.

Land-Based Casinos & Online Partners

The online casino operator needs a partnership with a brick-and-mortar casino in Pennsylvania to offer legal and licensed online gambling in Pennsylvania. There are currently 14 land-based casinos in Pennsylvania.

The most prominent land-based casinos with online presence are:

Land-Based CasinoOnline Casino Partner
Rivers Casino PhiladelphiaBetRivers and PlaySugarHouse
Harrah’s CasinoCaesars Online Casino
Valley forgeFanDuel
MGM Resorts BetMGM online casino
Mohegan Sun PoconoUnibet
Penn National Race CourseDraftKings Casino
Presque IslePresque Isle
Parx CasinoParx Online Casino
Hollywood CasinoHollywood Online Casino
Mount Airy CasinoPokerstars Casino

Other Legal Gambling Options in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania offers a diverse array of gambling options to suit every preference and interest. From traditional casino games to sports betting and horse racing, the Keystone State provides a wide range of choices for those interested in online or land-based gambling. 

Beyond casinos, these are the other legal forms of gambling available in PA:

✅ Online Sports Betting & Land-Based Sports Betting:

Pennsylvania boasts a thriving sports betting industry, with both online and land-based options available. Players can wager on a variety of sports, including football, basketball, baseball, and more, at licensed sportsbooks across the state. 

✅ Daily Fantasy Sports:

Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS) are immensely popular in Pennsylvania, offering players the chance to draft fantasy teams and compete for cash prizes in daily or weekly contests. Major DFS operators like DraftKings and FanDuel operate in the state, providing a wide range of contests across various sports leagues.

✅ Horse Racing:

Horse racing has a rich history in Pennsylvania, with several racetracks offering live racing events and simulcast wagering. Players can place bets on thoroughbred, standardbred, and quarter-horse races, both in-person and through online platforms like TVG and BetAmerica.

✅ Online Bingo & Land-Based Bingo:

Bingo enthusiasts in Pennsylvania can enjoy both online and land-based bingo games. Traditional bingo halls host regular games with cash prizes, while online bingo sites and apps offer a convenient way to play from anywhere. 

✅ Online Poker & Land-Based Poker:

Poker is a beloved pastime in Pennsylvania, with numerous land-based poker rooms and online poker platforms available to players. Whether you prefer Texas Hold'em, Omaha, or Stud, you'll find a variety of cash games, tournaments, and sit-and-go events to suit your skill level and bankroll.

✅ Charitable Gambling:

Charitable gambling is permitted in Pennsylvania, with organizations like churches, schools, and non-profit groups eligible to host fundraising events such as raffles, bingo nights, and casino-style games. These events provide a fun way for charitable organizations to raise funds for worthy causes while complying with state regulations.

A Brief Timeline of Pennsylvania’s Online Gambling Legislation

Being one of the most recent states to approve legal and regulated online gaming, Pennsylvania took a stride that many locals thought wouldn’t be possible.

The HB 271 bill passed both the State Senate and House, but their taxes are still somewhat problematic. At this time, the state levies every online casino operating in PA a tax rate of 54% and 55% on slot machines. These high tax rates are considered by many exorbitantly high, especially if you compare them to the neighboring New Jersey. In Garden State, the tax rate stands at only 15% of the gambling revenue.

On the bright side, PA residents will now have access to a wide range of online gambling sites, including those situated outside the state. That’s still a win, at least for local players.

Let's take a look at the timeline from the first rumors from lawmakers concerning online gambling starting in 2013. In the following years, there were several instances where lawmakers came close to passing a bill, only for the process to hit a wall at the 11th hour. But thankfully, this wild adventure eventually bore fruit. So let’s see how online gambling crossed the finish line in 2017.

2013

Representative Tina Davis of District 141 spearheaded the earliest efforts to legalize online gambling in PA. She introduced HB 1235 (House Bill 1235), enabling existing casinos and slot machine licensed operators to apply for an additional license for online casino operations. However, the bill made it as far as House Committee on Gaming Oversight, and they decided that the bill be delayed until 2015.

Despite the failure, it became crystal clear that PA was taking online gambling quite seriously. This showed that the SR 273 bill tasked Econsult Solutions to measure the economic impacts of online gaming.

2014

2014 was the year of relative dormancy.  In June, Senator Edwin Erickson proposed an online gambling bill SB 1386, but it failed to generate interest, and they never brought it up for a vote.

2015

In 2015 four online gambling bills were proposed:

  • HB 649: Proposed by John Payne, the bill required a 16% tax rate on gross gaming revenue and licensing of $5 million for any casino operator.
  • HB 920: The bill was proposed by Tina Davis, and it was mostly a copy of HB 649.
  • HB 695: This was an online poker-only bill that required licensing fees of $5 million per operator and tax revenue of 14%.
  • SB 900:  this bill was a joint effort by Senators Elder Vogel, Joseph Scarnati, Robert Tomlinson, and Kim Ward. It suggested a permit fee of $10 million and a 54% tax on gross revenue.

However, all efforts to approve these bills became futile, but they did not lose all hope.

2016

In late June, the new HB 2150 was passed by the house, and this was the first time an online gambling bill sailed through all the State legislative chambers. In the following month, Governor Wolf approximated $100 million for the online gamlbing expansion as a part of a $1.3 billion revenue package. Everything looked good until the Senate decided to sit on gaming reform till the following fall.

2017

In 2017, they finally passed online gambling legislation, but as you can see, the journey towards legalization in Pennsylvania hasn’t been a smooth ride. On October 30th, Wolf late signed an unlimited budget which added HB 271 into the law, and PA became the fourth state in the US to legalize online gambling.

2018

On May 14th, 2018, things took a complete turn in PA and across the country when the Supreme Court of the United States struck down the PASPA (Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act). The PASPA was a federal ban on sports betting that had taken effect in 1992 across the country. Finally, there was room to regulate online sports betting in whichever way each state saw fit!